Your question has been sent.
Expect an answer!
Croton Reservoir Tavern in New York City
Restaurant
Open
108 W 40td St, New York City, NY 10018-2699, New York City
Overview
Cuisine
- American
- Bar
- Pub
- Grill
- Gluten Free Options
Features
- Reservations
- Seating
- Waitstaff
- Television
- Wheelchair Accessible
- Serves Alcohol
- Full Bar
Good for
- Bar scene
- Special occasions
- Families witd children
Restaurant Hours
Monday
11:00 am
Wednesday
11:00 am
Friday
11:00 am
Sunday
11:00 am
Get an answer
Ask a Question
is croton reservoir tavern open on sunday
Not to my knowledge
Hello! My husband and me are looking for a restaurant for the new year party. Is it possible to make now a reservation please? We are two people. Thanks
Food is a very low quality
Good for lunch with adults and 7 year old???
Yes.
Review
DH
Dennis Higgins
google
04.24.2024
Good selection of beers. Decent happy hour prices for Midtown.
KM
Keven Melara
google
11.25.2018
I’ve been coming here for 3 years since working in Midtown. Nice bartenders and great service .. very friendly. Happy hour is poppin n prices are good. Note: only downstairs is happy hour but it’s an awesome vibe.
RC
Ryan Crosby
google
10.27.2018
Good bar good food popular spot in this area. It gets pretty crowded at night but you have two levels to hit which helps.
TG
Tori Golden
google
10.16.2018
Best decision made coming here. We walked all around time square but it was too touristy so not too far away near Bryant Park we found this restaurant and the food was incredible! the restaurant has a nice bar but a classy vibe and low lighting. Not crowded and very comfortable. Food was so damn good. Service was great too.
IV
Irene Vagianos
google
09.27.2018
Good lunch at the bar but tough to get a bartender's attention after work. Average drink selection - challenging if you'd like a good glass of wine.
DV
Diane Ventura
google
09.11.2018
Great ambiance for a tavern and burger was delicious. I liked the menu and the variety it offered. I definitely would go back.
DB
Dan Brilliant
google
09.09.2018
Great list of bourbons, whiskeys and scotches from around the world. Friendly knowledgeable staff.
JB
Joshua Barbee
google
08.26.2018
We had a delicious business lunch at Croton Reservoir Tavern. The service was friendly, professional and attentive. The food was prepared well, fresh and excellent. We will definitely be recommending and visiting again.
DL
Donna Lehigh
google
08.23.2018
Love this restaurant! Great food! Easy walk from Radio City Music Hall.
JC
Joe C.
google
08.10.2018
Excellent food and service. Great atmosphere. Check out the basement bar.
MA
M-P Amendolare
google
07.26.2018
Nice quiet spot for drinks, music isn’t too loud so you can have a conversation with friends.
SA
Suzette Azariah Gunn
google
07.18.2018
Chill vibe, great happy hour drinks and prices. Cool wait staff, good eats. A nice low key place to chill without having to be fancy. Good for friends and date.
TM
Terence McGuire
google
07.16.2018
I like this place, the food is quite good, it's well staffed and comfortable.
VR
Valerie Robinson
google
07.09.2018
We had Buffalo wings, and sliders. I dont know if the sliders were good, I didnt eat any. The buffalo wings were average at best.
PS
Paul Swithers
google
07.01.2018
We went here for drinks after a work event and shared a few standard bar appetizers. Everything was good. The ambience, the service, the clientele, the food. For a very touristy neighborhood, this had a good enough city vibe that I would go back if I were nearby again.
LD
Ladi Dre
google
04.18.2018
Open late on a Monday for food ... Entrees and sides ala carte. New drink menu, but fixings for drinks not arriving for 2 more days 🤦🏻♀️. Very chilly inside.
MR
Mike Riva
google
03.17.2018
Food was delicous & reasonably priced. Nice atmosphere, attentive friendly staff. Good drinks.We will definitely dine there again.Unfortunately, I forgot to take pix of food - beautifully plated.
ES
Esses S
google
03.16.2018
Tight space, but the food is always great!
BC
Benjamin Costabile
google
03.05.2018
This is my favorite local bar. If it’s for a sit down dinner, or a drink downstairs during happy hour, service is always on point and the staff is super friendly. The bartenders always hook you up too, super dope.
TJ
Teddy Jeanty
google
01.17.2018
Best Friday happy hour spot. In the basement 🌝
TG
Tyler Gitter
google
11.07.2017
Wow, fantastic. Great selection of beers and scotch. Food is great. Service was great. A+
ET
Executive Thrillseeker
google
10.27.2017
Nice place in the craziness of Bryant park! Service here was good. Beer line can use some checking as we had a couple flat lagers in our group...but all in all good place to visit if you’re in the area
PE
Peter Engelmaier
google
10.03.2017
The Service and food were excellent for our party if 13. I'll be back for sure
BG
BobbiJo Girroir
google
09.09.2017
Was great, we needed to catch our tour bus.acroos the way at the park so I wanted to book a close restaurant. The reservation app was easy & I am glad I used it. There were about 5 groups who walked in approx the same time, I told the greeter my name and we were sat right away. Excellent food options and the waitstaff were wonderful, it had been a long day touring the city and I just wanted a steady flow of 3 cocktails and they catered to that want, also catered to my daughters dietary wants in the food prep. Would go.again next time we are touring the city.
mk
matthew katz
google
08.22.2017
Just had late night drinks nice spot for this
MC
Michele Ché TV
google
08.05.2017
Too dark and too small for a big party. There is NO CELL PHONE SERVICE when you are down in the "private room section". Also business sign out front is very dark and incognito that if you are looking for this address at night you might walk right past it. A friend of mine and I passed it the night we went. Well drinks are $10.
BM
Brian Maysa
google
08.02.2017
Great after work drink specials. Highly recommend the downstairs bar.
AL
Alex Levine
google
07.23.2017
Didnt have any food so the hostess very nicely rearranged existing patrons so me and my guest could sit together at the bar. The drink selection is amazing if you are into scotch and DECENT if into bourbon and very limited rye. My only comment would be for the bar to expand their bourbon and rye offerings. But all in all a very positive experience
MR
Marc Ras
google
07.18.2017
I love this place. Been here two times and both times great friendly service. The food is great and also has a good bar crowd that is not onto of you while dining. My new go to place
JP
J. Peter Marinelli
google
06.09.2017
Good pub grub. Sports on TV. Attentive staff.
mj
muse joseph
google
05.23.2017
Nice, easy going, laid back vibe. well prepared drinks. obviously geared toward an older crowd. music wasn't so loud to be obnoxious, but also never went later than the 60s. mostly early Motown and other pop tunes of that era. it was early afternoon, so maybe their catalog time travels @ sundown. Their frozen sangria hit the spot. didn't really enjoy their Passion Pit cocktail. Great treating bar bites. pretty nice after work spot.
EG
Eric Garcia
google
05.01.2017
I like this place but it’s a bit expensive for lunch and or dinner but then again it’s just outside Times Square. I usually arrange meet and greets and or first dates since the decor is nice and the menu offers many types of choices. It’s also near my office which helps too.
LI
Liz Irizarry
google
04.12.2017
It was good. The bartender tended to us rightaway, a little serious but not rude. She looked to know her drinks. We went downstairs andhad s burger. The waitress was very nice. The food was good, regular.
AA
Alok Agrawal
google
03.20.2017
Good burgers.Good for afternoon meeting and lunches.I got veggie options as well
DC
Daniel Cooke
google
01.22.2017
Great service. Great scotch selection.
ML
Michael Landi
google
01.08.2017
Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale restaurants. Lunch is booming and dinner is intimate. I'm a regular now.
DZ
Daniil Zarkh
google
01.01.2017
Very nice bar with great food and drinks.
JA
Jason Ansible
google
11.22.2016
Nice service and good drinks, relative for what it is. Also they require a mask if you walk inside to use the bathroom, which is a good sign.
SP
Stephen Pile
google
10.25.2016
The fries Lovely place. Great vibe and inviting atmosphere. My server for the day, Justin was very helpful!!... Top man! The fries were well done. I will definitely come back.
SK
Steve Kupitz
google
10.12.2016
My wife and I stopped in since we had an hour to kill before our flight back home to Chicago and we had a great time. Granted we weren’t here for very long nor did we have anything off of their food menu but here were the positives: the staff was friendly, professional and attentive, the restaurant and bar area were clean and the atmosphere was great. I loved the dark wood and the huge selection of whiskey. If we’re ever in New York City again, we’d gladly stop here again.
TM
Tom Moncho
google
10.02.2016
Great atmosphere and food.
MH
Miguel H
google
09.04.2016
Fancy bar with a beautiful decoration. They are based oon the reservoir that formerly existed where now stands the New York Public Library. Good selection of beers and ok prices. The service was also very good. On a Thursday night it was not crowded and quiet, just what we were looking for. It has a downstairs floor that was not opened.
MC
Marcia Corcella
google
07.17.2016
Food!!!I've tried a little bit of everything from the Croton kitchen but I love their Mac & Cheese! It is super filling and i always ask to add chicken and bacon to top it off.Their nachos, hummus, & sweet potato fries all pass as a good bar snack.
DR
Danny Rowland
google
06.24.2016
It is a nice place. They keep dim lighting inside which makes for a decent atmosphere. They play music, but not too loud. There is a downstairs area and bar that is nice and a little more cozy. In the winter they have coat racks out for you to hang your things up if you would like, but they didn't force us to. The bathrooms were clean, the drinks were reasonable, the service was quick and friendly.
jm
jose miguel isaza herrera
google
06.17.2016
Had a great time on a Saturday night with my two special ladies. Great vibe and a great service as well.
WK
Willem Koenders
google
05.11.2016
Came here with a client to have a few drinks at the bar. Always plenty of folks. Good that the music isn’t too loud.
JE
Javier Evans
google
03.13.2016
Great midtown bar located near Bryant Park.
MB
Maceo Brown
google
02.12.2016
Good, upscale pub atmosphere. The waitress and other staff were quite pleasant. Nice vibe for an after work drink or quick dinner.
PS
Phil Serafino
google
01.17.2016
Great beer list and the appetizers were quite tasty; especially liked the artichoke dip. (Didn't try any of the main courses). Nice atmosphere. Yasmin the hostess and Tanya, our waitress, took good care of us. Highly recommended.
DH
Dave Hobbs
google
01.14.2016
Went here to the downstairs room for a corporate event. Service was great. Food was good (buffet line). Music was a little loud for easy conversations you generally get for business stuff. But the DJ was good. I'd go back for sure.